|

POSTED 01 DECEMBER, 2002
The Four Gateways of Messianic, Two-House Theology
by
J.K. McKee
editor@tnnonline.net
The Messianic community is at a crossroads and people are looking
for answers.[1]
In our day, many Christians are being led into
Messianic congregations and fellowships, because
they know that there is more “out there.” The
Holy Spirit is moving on these people to seek
greater Biblical truth, maturity, and to cede
more control of their lives over to God. These
individuals feel a strong love for Israel, and a
connection to the Jewish people. As a result,
many of these Christians enter into the
Messianic movement, because they desire to live
a life more consistent with that of our Lord
Yeshua the Messiah, embracing their Hebraic
Roots for more than just enrichment to
their faith, but as a lifestyle they should be
practicing on a consistent basis.
The things that are happening in our faith today are wonderful and
are indeed a sign that the return of the Messiah
is somehow approaching. But even though many are
turning to the Messianic movement, it would be
an understatement to say that we are
controversial. What we stand for goes against
some of the things that many have been taught in
the contemporary Church. How we live our
day-to-day lives in compliance with the Bible is
different than how many modern Christians go
about doing so. And, our steadfast claim that
Yeshua (Jesus) is the Messiah of Israel, does
not often win us many fans in the Jewish
community.
There are many issues that face us today as the Messianic
community. There are many questions that are
being posed that we cannot let go unanswered.
There are challenges that we must face if we
truly endeavor to be in the will of God and not
to be following our own humanistic, fleshly
desires.
Are we truly Israel?
It is not difficult for a Jewish Believer in Yeshua to know that he
or she is a part of Israel. But what of
non-Jewish Believers? To what extent are they
co-heirs (Ephesians 3:6) along with Jewish
Believers? Consider what the Apostle Paul wrote
to non-Jewish Believers in Asia Minor:
“Therefore
remember that formerly you, the Gentiles in the
flesh, who are called ‘Uncircumcision’ by the
so-called ‘Circumcision,’ which is
performed in the flesh by human hands—remember
that you were at that time separate from
Messiah, excluded from the commonwealth of
Israel, and strangers to the covenants of
promise, having no hope and without God in the
world. But now in Messiah Yeshua you who
formerly were far off have been brought near by
the blood of Messiah”
(Ephesians 2:11-13).
Paul tells these Believers that prior to their faith in Israel’s
Messiah they had been separate from Israel, but
recognizing Yeshua’s salvation they had been
brought near (cf. Isaiah 57:19), and the status
of being away from Israel had been reversed.
Non-Jewish Believers are a part of what is
literally the polity of Israel, or the
community, commonwealth people of Israel. The
Greek politeia (politeia)
means “the
right to be a member of a sociopolitical entity,
citizenship,”
and “a sociopolitical unit or body of
citizens, state, people, body politic.”[2]
Nowhere in ancient times did Paul teach that
these people were a part of a separate entity
known as “the Church.”[3]
Rather, they were part of the assembly or
congregation of Israel, “the Israel of God”
(Galatians 6:16)—and the same remains true until
today.
In our day, at the very least, many Christians are awakening to the
reality that they are inextricably connected to
“Israel,” whatever that is. While definitions of
“Israel” vary, ranging from the historical
Jewish people to the Land of Israel to the
assembly of all Believers, interest in “Israel”
is at an all-time high, and it is only
increasing with each passing day. This has
helped to balloon the Messianic movement with
scores of new people. At the same time, though,
it is not without its challenges.
Messianics such as myself advocate that all Believers who have
faith in the Messiah of Israel, Yeshua, are
indeed a part of Israel. They are not part of a
separate Church. Whether they be physical Israel
or not, they are indeed all called to be Israel
as defined by the Scriptures. In this article,
we examine some of the things currently going on
in the Messianic community that we all must
face, and how we might approach them in a
reasonable way.
The Call of Israel: Never to Give Up
If all Believers are indeed a part of Israel, and we are called to
live as Israel, it is imperative that we all
know what the rallying cry of Israel is. The
name “Israel” first appears in the Bible in
Genesis 32:28-29, and lays the important
groundwork for what the call upon God’s people
actually is:
“He
said, ‘Your name shall no longer be Jacob, but
Israel; for you have striven with God and
with men and have prevailed.’ Then Jacob
asked him and said, ‘Please tell me your name.’
But he said, ‘Why is it that you ask my name?’
And he blessed him there.”
The Hebrew verb sarah (hrf),
translated as “striven” or “struggled” (NIV)
here, appears in the Qal stem (simple action,
active voice) and specifically means “persist,
exert oneself, persevere” (BDB).[4]
We should all know the story quite well of how the Patriarch Jacob
endured through the night wrestling with the
angel (whom some believe was a Christophany of
Messiah Yeshua). We are told, “When
he saw that he had not prevailed against him, he
touched the socket of his thigh; so the socket
of Jacob's thigh was dislocated while he
wrestled with him. Then he said, ‘Let me go, for
the dawn is breaking.’ But he said, ‘I will not
let you go unless you bless me.’ So he said to
him, ‘What is your name?’ And he said, ‘Jacob’”
(Genesis 32:25-27).
By enduring or struggling through the night until daybreak, Jacob
(Heb. Ya’akov,
bq[y) demonstrated an internal urge and
desire to be blessed by God. The mortal Jacob
never gave up and continued fighting, even when
the supernatural being seemingly grew frustrated
and tiresome of their combat. But Jacob
continued, perhaps knowing that he could not
win, and it is for this reason why he was
renamed Yisrael (larfy) or Israel. J.H. Hertz gives us a very
important definition of Israel in his commentary
Pentateuch & Haftorahs:
“The name is clearly a title of victory; probably ‘a champion of
God’. The children of the Patriarch are
Israelites, Champions of God, Contenders for
the Divine, conquering by strength from Above.”[5]
This is extremely interesting and something that every Believer
in Yeshua should take note of. If we are
indeed all a part of Israel, via our faith in
Him, then we are called to be champions of God
and contenders for the Divine. We are to
represent the Lord here on Planet Earth and
strive for the Forces of Light. We wage battle
against Satan and his forces via the power of
God inside us. Paul writes in Philippians 3:14,
“I
press on toward the goal for the prize of the
upward call of God in Messiah Yeshua.” The Greek verb rendered as “press on”
is diōkō (diwkw), “to run swiftly in order to catch some person or
thing, to run after.” It also can mean “to
make to run or flee, put to flight, drive
away” (Thayer).[6]
As Believers in Yeshua, and as a part of Israel, we are all
called to endure. We are called to run toward
the things of faith that God has set before us,
and seek the rewards and prizes that await the
completion of our marathon race. Most
importantly, we are called to never give up, no
matter the cost. This cost may be our friends,
our family, our reputation, or perhaps even our
lives. But even so, if we are committed to the
Lord, we know that He runs our lives and that He
is sovereign. If we are in the Messiah,
regardless of what happens, we are in His care.
We must function as those who contend for the
faith and who will strive and fight with
the Divine fulfilling His mission, rather than
strive and fight against the Divine.
A Blessing to All Nations
Sadly, the history of Ancient Israel does not always reveal that
God’s people have been prevailing and contending
for Him. Israel’s history is anything but “hunky
dorey.” As with all people groups, the
temptations of sin have crept in and the enemy
has been allowed access. There have been
division and internal fighting which has led to
the Torah-required judgment of God upon His
people, and a series of dispersions into the
nations (cf. Deuteronomy chs. 28-30).
But many times when Satan intends something for evil, God will turn
it around for good. Consider the example of
Joseph and how his brothers sold him into
slavery. Joseph went down into Egypt and through
a series of trials became second only to
Pharaoh, being able to aid his family when they
came to Egypt during the famine (Genesis 50:20).
Even though there have been divisions and
dispersions for the people of Israel, what the
enemy intends to use for evil, God will use for
His purposes. Consider how synagogues and Jewish
communities outside the Land of Israel in the
First Century aided the Apostles significantly,
providing them some kind of a base for sharing
the good news of salvation with the nations.
The Apostle Paul considered the original promise given to Abraham,
“in
you all the families of the earth will be
blessed” (Genesis 12:3), to actually constitute
the gospel being proclaimed to him “beforehand”
(Galatians 3:8). Abraham’s seed is to bless
others. As the Lord promised Abraham, “indeed
I will greatly bless you, and I will greatly
multiply your seed as the stars of the heavens
and as the sand which is on the seashore; and
your seed shall possess the gate of their
enemies. In your seed all the nations of the
earth shall be blessed, because you have obeyed
My voice”
(Genesis 22:17-18).
The promise that God made to Abraham was that from his loins he
would have multitudes of physical descendants,[7]
who would then serve as the conduit of His
blessings to the entire human race. The same
promise of physical multiplicity was given to
Jacob in Genesis 35:11, “God
also said to him, ‘I am God Almighty; be
fruitful and multiply; a nation and a company of
nations shall come from you, and kings shall
come forth from you.’”
We have evidence in the Tanach (Old Testament) that these promises
were already being fulfilled after the time of
the Exodus. Moses attested in Deuteronomy 1:10,
“The Lord
your God has multiplied you, and behold, you are
this day like the stars of heaven in number.” Conservative Biblical scholars may estimate that at the time of
the Exodus the Ancient Israelites could have
numbered in the hundreds of thousands,[8]
shortly before Moses made this declaration.
Moses’ next words are extremely perplexing, as
he says, “May the
Lord,
the God of your fathers, increase you a
thousand-fold more than you are and bless you,
just as He has promised you!” (Deuteronomy
1:11).
If we take Moses’ words at face value, then how many descendants of
Israel are there on Planet Earth today? Is it
fair to suggest that the number exceeds today’s
Jewish population of 14-15 million? This is by
no means a suggestion that every person
is descended from the Patriarchs, but is a
simple question of whether this word has
continuing fulfillment today.
Obviously, the primary part of the promise that the Lord made to
Abraham about his seed blessing the world is
a reference to the Seed, who is the Messiah
Yeshua (cf. Galatians 3:16). Everything
must be focused around Messiah Yeshua, who
says “I
am the root and the descendant [seed] of David,
the bright morning star” (Revelation 22:16). But even so, Abraham’s offspring or
seed would have to be plural in order to bless
all nations—and those “descendants” would bless
all nations by bringing forth the truths of the
God of Israel from His Word and the message of
the Messiah (cf. Galatians 3:8).
Paul writes in Galatians 3:28-29, “There
is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave
nor free man, there is neither male nor female;
for you are all one in Messiah Yeshua. And if
you belong to Messiah, then you are Abraham's
descendants [seed], heirs according to promise.”
All people who make up God’s Commonwealth of
Israel (Ephesians 2:11-12) are equal in His
eyes, and are a part of His “one new humanity”
(Ephesians 2:15, NRSV/CJB) brought forth by the
work of Messiah Yeshua. Membership is by no
means determined by heredity, but rather by
faith.
A dictim in the Talmud, based on Genesis 17:5,[9]
observes how “At
first you were the father of Aram [the Arameans].
Now you are the father of the entire world”
(b.Berachot 13a),[10]
making all people connected to Abraham in some
way—most especially via the blessings that would
come forth from him. Anything having to do with
physical descent from the Patriarchs, be a
person a known Jew, a person with distant Jewish
ancestry, or a person with lost ancestry from
Ancient Israel—solely regards the
completion of yet-to-be-fulfilled prophecies in
the eschaton.[11]
And, since all of God’s people are a part of
Israel, all will be involved in it to one
degree or another.[12]
Many theologians throughout the centuries have interpreted
Galatians 3:29 as meaning that those who have
faith in Yeshua are of the spiritual seed of
Abraham, because Believers in Yeshua are to have
Abraham’s kind of faith. Having the faith of
Abraham is obviously important, but “spiritual
seed” is not exclusively what is meant by the
text.[13]
There is more for the understanding of
“descendants” (or even “progeny,” New Jerusalem
Bible) than some are willing to give credence
to. We are descendants of Abraham through our
union with the Messiah; we are descendants of
Abraham if we live like Abraham; we are
descendants of Abraham if we partake of
Abraham’s covenant promises. Likewise, many who
know the Messiah are descendants of Abraham, and
are recipients of the promises made to him
because of progeny.[14]
Considering the fact that both Abraham, and
later Jacob/Israel were to have multitudes of
physical descendants, what is being implied
here?
If there are some implications regarding physical seed to be
considered, they are not speaking of one
having to be of Abraham’s physical loins to “be
saved.” On the contrary, the emphasis of
being Abraham’s seed primarily speaks to how a
person lives his life and views the Bible—in
order to be a blessing to all! One can be of the
“seed” of Abraham via any number of ways. It
ultimately concerns the mission that God has for
Israel, and how all born again Believers today
should get to fulfill that mission as a part of
His chosen people. If one is Abraham’s seed via
bloodline, one is mandated by God to be a
blessing to others. And, if one is Abraham’s
seed via faith, one is to likewise be a
blessing, and be grateful to the physical
descendants from whom the Messiah came forth
(cf. Romans 11:29-32).
The Two Houses of Israel
Many of you are quite familiar with the history of Ancient Israel.
Israel was a united kingdom under the reigns of
Kings Saul, David, and Solomon. But even though
the kingdom was united, there were divisions,
aside from the obvious tribal distinctions. For
example, 1 Samuel 18:16 tells us “all
Israel and Judah loved David, and he went out
and came in before them.”
Some kind of division between Israel and Judah
existed before King David ascended to the throne
(i.e., Joshua 11:21). It manifested itself much
more clearly after David’s son King Solomon died
and his son Rehoboam came to power. Because of
Solomon’s worship of gods other than the God of
Israel, the kingdom was to be divided between
Rehoboam and Jeroboam. 1 Kings 11:30-33 speaks
of the Lord offering Jeroboam, then a servant of
King Solomon, ten of the twelve tribes of
Israel:
“Then
Ahijah took hold of the new cloak which was on
him and tore it into twelve pieces. He said to
Jeroboam, ‘Take for yourself ten pieces; for
thus says the
Lord,
the God of Israel, “Behold, I will tear the
kingdom out of the hand of Solomon and give you
ten tribes (but he will have one tribe, for the
sake of My servant David and for the sake of
Jerusalem, the city which I have chosen from all
the tribes of Israel), because they have
forsaken Me, and have worshiped Ashtoreth the
goddess of the Sidonians, Chemosh the god of
Moab, and Milcom the god of the sons of Ammon;
and they have not walked in My ways, doing what
is right in My sight and observing My
statutes and My ordinances, as his father David
did.”’”
Biblical history tells us the rest of the story. Because of this
idolatry, the Kingdom of Israel split into the
Northern Kingdom of Israel/Ephraim and the
Southern Kingdom of Judah. While there was some
intermingling and relations between the two
groups, the political division remained
permanent. In fact, when the kingdoms were first
split, the Lord had to tell the Southern Kingdom
not to amass its forces so that it could
re-conquer the Northern Kingdom, because the
division was from Him:
“Speak
to Rehoboam the son of Solomon, king of Judah,
and to all Israel in Judah and Benjamin, saying,
‘Thus says the
Lord,
“You shall not go up or fight against your
relatives; return every man to his house, for
this thing is from Me.”’ So they listened to the
words of the
Lord
and returned from going against Jeroboam” (2 Chronicles 11:3-4).
We know what happened later. As the Northern Kingdom continued to
disobey the Lord and it devolved further and
further into idolatry, it was conquered by
Assyria. Many of its people were assimilated
into the nations, per the Assyrian practice of
deportation. Aside from individuals loyal to the
God of Israel, and those who fled to the
Southern Kingdom, the Northern Kingdom of
Israel/Ephraim was never corporately
heard from again.[15]
The Patriarch Jacob had prophesied centuries earlier that Ephraim
would become “the fullness of the nations”
(Genesis 48:19, YLT) or melo ha’goyim (~yAGh-alm),
a likely part of the mystery of Israel’s grand
redemption later referenced by the Apostle Paul
in Romans 11:25: “For
I do not want you, brethren, to be uninformed of
this mystery—so that you will not be wise in
your own estimation—that a partial hardening has
happened to Israel until the fullness of the
Gentiles[16]
has come in.”
Until this group of people returns to the fold,
mature in the Lord, then the complete
restoration of Israel will not be accomplished.
The Southern Kingdom of Judah experienced its own dispersion as it
also practiced idolatry against God. Judah was
taken captive by the Babylonians, but was able
to return to the Land of Israel. The Jewish
people experienced another exile at the hands of
the Romans in 70 C.E., but then began returning
to the Promised Land through the advent of
Zionism in the late 1800s, and helped establish
the State of Israel in 1948. For approximately
2,500 years, the Jewish people have been—without
any dispute—identifiable as “Israel.”
They also possess an irrevocable calling that
must be honored (Romans 11:29).
Has all Israel been reunited?
Even though the Jewish people are certainly legitimate Israelites
and descendants of the Patriarchs, are there
many more descendants of Israel out there? A
division between the Two Houses of Israel—the
descendants of the Northern Kingdom and the
Southern Kingdom—would certainly still exist if
there are prophecies regarding their
reunification that are yet-to-be-fulfilled.
There are many in today’s Christianity, Judaism, and for that same
matter Messianic Judaism, who believe that the
Two Houses of Israel have already been reunited.
(Although there are many in Orthodox Judaism who
believe that all Israel has yet to be reunited.)[17]
I do not believe that they can make a solid
Scriptural basis for this claim—not
because as a non-Jewish Believer I am somehow
claiming to be “Ephraim”—but because of the
expectations seen in the Tanach. Consider the
following prophecy concerning Judah and
scattered Israel/Ephraim from Ezekiel 37:25-28:
“They
will live on the land that I gave to Jacob My
servant, in which your fathers lived; and they
will live on it, they, and their sons and their
sons' sons, forever; and David My servant will
be their prince forever. I will make a covenant
of peace with them; it will be an everlasting
covenant with them. And I will place them and
multiply them, and will set My sanctuary in
their midst forever. My dwelling place also will
be with them; and I will be their God, and they
will be My people. And the nations will know
that I am the
Lord
who sanctifies Israel, when My sanctuary is in
their midst forever.”
Has this prophecy been fulfilled? Is God’s Sanctuary established in
the Land of Israel for all the nations of the
world to see? Also consider the fact that
Ezekiel 37:24 directly states, “My
servant David will be king over them, and they
will all have one shepherd; and they will walk
in My ordinances and keep My statutes and
observe them.”
David is representative of the Messiah.
If indeed the Two Houses of Israel were fully
reunited in the past, then Messiah Yeshua would
be present in Jerusalem right now ruling and
reigning over the world. But He has not yet
returned, and thus we are still waiting for the
reunion of all Israel and the other
parties involved.[18]
But do not just take my word for it. Popular author Tim LaHaye
tells us, in regard to Bible prophecy, “The
Kingdom of David and Solomon split in 931 B.C.,
becoming Israel and Judah, all tribes are
represented and the nation will be united.”[19]
John F. Walvoord observes in his Every
Prophecy of the Bible, “The situation where
these two kingdoms were divided will end, and as
this and other prophecies predict, the two
kingdoms will become one nation (cf. Jer. 3:18;
23:5-6; 30:3; Hosea 1:11; Amos 9:11). No
fulfillment has ever been recorded in history,
and the future regathering of Israel will occur
in the Millennium.”[20]
These two dispensationalists recognize some
level of future fulfillment that cannot go
unaddressed.
Many of us believe that in our day the Two Houses of Israel are in
the process of being reunited. They are being
reunited as many Jewish people turn to faith in
Messiah Yeshua, and many non-Jewish Believers
(possibly including some from that scattered
House of Israel/Ephraim) turn toward their
Hebraic Roots and embrace a lifestyle of Torah
obedience. As important as it has been to see
the advent of Messianic Judaism since the 1960s,
and many Jewish people welcoming Yeshua into
their lives as Messiah—is there something
more going on with many non-Jewish Believers
being led into the Messianic movement? We may
have to wait in order to fully find out. But
if the prophecies of Israel’s greater
restoration have begun, then this will one day
result in the return of Yeshua the Messiah and
the establishment of His Kingdom on Earth. It
is something that will affect the entire world.
The Movement Today
As can and should be expected, much of what we have just discussed
is new, and also presents some controversies.
Known by a variety of names from Messianic
Israel, Judah and Ephraim, the Two Houses of
Israel, or just Two-House, there are many
Believers coming to some kind of awareness of
the Two Houses of Israel and are seeing
themselves as a part of Israel, not necessarily
a part of “the Church” or “the Synagogue,”
exclusively. But as this has been occurring, and
I believe it is an important part of our
Father’s end-time plan, many questions and
issues have arisen. The subject matter has been
approached in a variety of ways, some good—and
some not so good. Some view it as a matter of
eschatology (such as myself), and others view it
as their principal spiritual identity (even more
important than personal salvation).
These questions and issues are expected. Ezekiel 37:18 tells us
that those who participate in Israel’s
restoration will say, “Will you not show us what
you mean by these?” (RSV). The implications of
the Two Houses of Israel are much more than
knowing whether or not one is a part of Israel.
The implications change how a person reads the
Bible and lives his or her daily life. How do we
relate to the Jewish people who do not know
Messiah Yeshua? How do we relate to our
Christian forebearers who diligently proclaimed
the gospel, but did not understand their Hebraic
Roots as we do today? While we may not have all
of the answers until the Messiah returns, it is
imperative that we not ignore the challenges
that lie before us.
The Four Gateways of Our Theology
Because of the current controversial nature of the Two-House
teaching,[21]
and indeed the fact that it is presently
rejected by most Christians and Messianic Jews,
it is absolutely imperative on those of us who
believe that the Lord is reuniting all Israel,
to define our beliefs and continually refine our
theology. If we can understand what God has
started to do in our day, by beginning to
restore all Israel, we can properly formulate
those things on which we need to concentrate.
The Two-House understanding needs to be
something viable from the Biblical text, as
opposed to being something that is aberrant, off
the wall, and something that should be
avoided—lest we fall into the traps of others
who have addressed what some call the “Lost
Tribes” before. What we are actually addressing
is not the “Lost Tribes,” but are instead
overlooked prophecies of Israel’s restoration.
We are observing what is going on in today’s
Messianic movement, wondering if there is
something more.
I give you my four gateways of Messianic, Two-House theology. These
four sub-categories of Biblical study will no
doubt constitute what most of us will focus on
in the years and decades ahead, as all Israel is
reunited and the Messianic community grows and
gains new adherents.
#1 Foundational Doctrine
Foundational Doctrine should be a very obvious area. This includes
important issues as they relate to the core
beliefs of our faith. Topics that need to be
addressed in this category include: the nature
of God and His plurality, the Divinity of
Messiah Yeshua, the doctrine of salvation, and
eternal punishment. Additional issues include
the gospel message, proper discipleship for new
Believers, and the spiritual gifts. These would
be definite areas where commonality needs to be
expressed with our evangelical Christian
heritage, and the views of mainline Messianic
Judaism.
#2 Ecclesiology
Ecclesiology is the study of who God’s elect or ekklēsia is.
This comprises our understanding of the nature
of the assembly or congregation of the redeemed,
and the roles that individuals play within it.
It involves the study of what the Two Houses of
Israel actually are, and how they and their
companions make up God’s chosen people. It
addresses how a person being a part of Israel
impacts how we view the Bible, and the mission
of God’s people in the world. An overlooked area
would be the new status of human beings
inaugurated by the work of Yeshua, and how this
affects Israel’s restoration.[22]
An important area of study that ecclesiology also involves is
responding to the false teachings of
dispensationalism and replacement theology.
Dispensationalism advocates that God has two
groups of elect, and that all of the Bible is
not for all of His people. Replacement
theology is the idea that “the Church” has
replaced Israel in the Lord’s eternal plan.
Suffice it to say, as we discuss the teaching of
the reunification of the Two Houses of Israel,
it is absolutely imperative that we address
these two false viewpoints.
#3 Torah Application
Torah Application is the area relating to the role that the
Torah plays in our lives as Messianic Believers.
We do not believe, as much of contemporary
Christianity does, that the Torah or the Law of
Moses was done away with in the New Testament.
We fully believe that the Torah’s guidelines are
to be followed by Believers today, although we
do recognize that Messiah Yeshua came in
fulfillment of its sacrificial requirements via
His atoning work on the cross.
This is the most controversial of all the areas, because degrees of
Torah observance vary throughout the Messianic
community. Some follow a level of halachah
consistent with Orthodox Judaism, others want
nothing to do with Jewish tradition, and then
many such as myself follow a level of
halachah most consistent with
Conservative-Reform Judaism. This area cannot go
unanswered or unaddressed. While confronting
lawlessness and antinomianism, which has led to
a great erosion of ethics and morality in much
of today’s Church, so must we also discuss how
the Torah is to be applied in our lives and why
it is important that we study these foundational
Scriptures.[23]
#4 Eschatology
Eschatology regards our teachings of the Last Days and directly
affects how we see Israel restored. It is
extremely important that we have a good working
model of the end-times, because of the reality
that the Two Houses of Israel being reunited are
to play an important role in world events prior
to Yeshua’s return. While overlooked by many,
especially because of the heated discussions
that can ensue because of the Last Days, it is
nevertheless incumbent upon us to develop our
own viable and reasonable eschatological
teachings.
While the end-times are by no means a salvation issue, it is
important that we develop a working Two-House
prophecy model that is pre-millennial and post-tribulational,
but fluidic enough so that it considers the fact
that we live in a changing world. Our model of
the end-times must also not try to
make any predictions—complete with Date X chosen
for Yeshua’s return—about the future or restrict
our eternal God to a human timetable.
Challenges Before Us
This article has only scratched the surface of where we are today.
It is important that each one of us sees
ourselves as a part of Israel, composed of
Judah, scattered Israel/Ephraim, and their
companions—and not part of a “Church” or
“Synagogue” that may be completely separate from
what the Lord has started. It is imperative that
we begin defining who we are—and
not necessarily who we are not,
taking the missional imperatives of being Israel
more seriously. We must, through the empowerment
of the Holy Spirit, begin to take the
understanding of Israel’s restoration and deal
with the controversial issues that lie before
us. It is a restoration that will affect
everyone, and it is imperative for us to
present this as an inclusive plan of our
Father’s, not one where people are
excluded (cf. Isaiah 49:6).
A person who is a part of Israel is called to endure with God and
meet the challenges of life head on. We cannot
back down in the sight of battle, but must stay
the course. The Lord expects us to make a
positive difference and declare His goodness to
the entire world. Are we willing to do this? Are
we willing to make the required sacrifices? Will
we be able to take the heat? Are we willing to
do the work necessary, even in the sight of both
external and internal opposition?
May we indeed fight the good fight of faith! Let us be the Kingdom
of priests He has called us to be (Exodus 19:6;
1 Peter 2:9)!
J.K. McKee (B.A., University of Oklahoma; M.A., Asbury
Theological Seminary) is the editor of TNN Online (www.tnnonline.net)
and is a Messianic apologist. He is author of several books,
including: The New Testament Validates Torah, Torah In the
Balance, Volume I, and When Will the Messiah Return?.
He has also written many articles on the Two Houses of Israel
and Biblical theology, and is presently focusing on Messianic
commentaries on various books of the Bible.
NOTES
[1]
This article has been reproduced from
the paperback edition of
Introduction to
Things Messianic,
pp 85-98.
[2]
BDAG,
845.
[3]
Do recall the connections
between ekklēsia (ekklhsia)
and qahal (lhq).
Cf. Jack P. Lewis, “qāhāl,” in TWOT,
2:790; Thayer, 196; K.L. Schmidt,
“ekklēsía,” in
TDNT,
397.
[4]
BDB,
975.
[5]
J.H. Hertz, ed.,
Pentateuch & Haftorahs (London:
Soncino Press, 1960), 124.
[6]
Thayer,
153.
[7]
The Hebrew zera ([rz)
means “sowing, seed, offspring” and “descendants,
posterity; seed of the woman” (BDB,
282).
[8]
Consult the FAQ on the
TNN website “Exodus,
numbers of.”
[9]
“No longer shall your
name be called Abram, but your name
shall be Abraham; for I will make you
the father of a multitude of nations”
(Genesis 17:5).
[10]
The Babylonian Talmud:
A Translation and Commentary.
[11]
Including, but not
limited to: Isaiah 11:12-16; Jeremiah
10:6-10; Ezekiel 37:15-28; Zechariah
10:6-10.
[12]
Do note that the emphasis
of equality for all in Messiah first
within Israel, followed by the prophetic
expectation of Israel’s greater
restoration, is not one commonly
emphasized in today’s Messianic
Two-House sub-movement. Yet, I believe
it is the safest approach to use that
will do justice to the Biblical text.
Consult the author’s article “Contemporary
Options Concerning ‘Israel.’”
[13]
Grk. tou Abraam sperma
(tou
Abraam sperma);
“Abraham’s offspring” (RSV), “‘issue’ of
Abraham” (REB).
[14]
Cf. Stern, Jewish New
Testament Commentary, 549.
[15]
For a further discussion,
consult B.E. Kelle and B.A. Strawn,
“History of Israel 5: Assyrian Period,”
in Bill T. Arnold and H.G.M. Williamson,
eds., Dictionary of the Old Testament
Historical Books (Downers Grove, IL:
InterVarsity, 2005), pp 468-469.
Kelle and Strawn note how
“The presence of Israelite exiles in
Mesopotamia after 720 BCE is attested
also by the appearance of West Semitic
personal names in Assyrian texts, but
the occasional references suggests that
Israelite ethnic and national identity
was lost within a few generations”
(Ibid., 469).
[16]
Grk. to plērōma tōn
ethnōn (to
plhrwma twn eqnwn);
see Adam Clarke’s Commentary on the
Bible, as he notes linguistic
connections between
~yAGh-alm
and
plhrwma twn
eqnwn
in Romans 11:25.
[17]
Cf. b.Sanhedrin
110b, for a summary of the Rabbinic
debate.
[18]
Take important note that
the Two-House reunification involves the
“companions” of Judah and Ephraim
(Ezekiel 37:16). This means that more
people than solely physical
Israelites are involved—those who have
joined themselves to the God of Israel
are involved and considered as though
they are native Israelites. Far from
being exclusive, the prophecies
of Israel’s restoration are quite
inclusive.
We are reminded once
again, “it is clear that ‘Israel as a
light to the nations’ is no peripheral
theme within the canonical process. The
nations are the matrix of Israel’s life,
the raison d’être of her very existence”
(Christensen, “Nations,” in
ABD,
4:1037).
[19]
Tim LaHaye, ed., Tim
LaHaye Prophecy Study Bible
(Chattanooga: AMG Publishers, 2000),
873.
[20]
John F. Walvoord,
Every Prophecy of the Bible
(Colorado Springs: Chariot Victor
Publishing, 1999), pp 186-187.
[21]
This is in no small part
due to some of the current Two-House
proponents or “leaders” (cf. Galatians
2:6) who have closely associated some
aberrant teachings with the basic
message, and an almost
unwillingness for Messianic Jewish
leaders to simply sit down and honestly
discuss the relevant Biblical texts.
[22]
For a further discussion,
consult the author’s exegetical paper on
Galatians 3:28, “Biblical
Equality and Today’s Messianic Movement.”
[23]
It will also be incumbent
upon us to understand the effect of
Higher Criticism on the Pentateuch,
which has derided not only Mosaic
authorship/involvement in its
composition, but also its reliability as
Biblical history.
For a further
examination, consult Walter C. Kaiser,
The Old Testament Documents: Are They
Reliable and Relevant? (Downers
Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2001), and the
author’s workbook A Survey of the
Tanach for the Practical Messianic.
|